Choosing Between Re-roofing or Roof Sealing Solutions

When it comes to addressing an aging roof, homeowners are commonly faced with two options: opt for a roof sealing solution or invest in a full re-roof. Both approaches have their pros and cons, but understanding the long-term implications of each can help you make the right choice for your home. Roof sealing solutions and membranes may initially seem appealing due to their lower upfront cost, but these options come with significant limitations when compared to reroofing with COLORSTEEL®. Let’s explore the key factors to consider when deciding which solution is right for your home.

Security: Warranty and Protection

One of the first things to assess when comparing roof sealing and reroofing is the warranty that comes with each option. Roof sealing solutions generally offer waterproofing warranties of up to 10 years. While this may seem like a reasonable amount of time, it’s important to recognise that sealing is often more of a temporary solution.

In contrast, reroofing with COLORSTEEL® comes with a warranty of up to 50 years for corrosion to perforation.

Longevity: Addressing the Root of the Problem

Roof sealing is often viewed as a short-term, cosmetic fix. While it can extend the life of an aging roof, it doesn’t address any underlying structural issues that may be present. Rust, corrosion, and water damage can be problems in older roofs, and these issues are not solved by a sealing solution alone. In fact, sealing can sometimes mask these problems, leading to potentially more significant repairs down the road.

On the other hand, reroofing provides a comprehensive solution by completely replacing the old roof with new materials, eliminating any existing issues. By choosing to reroof, homeowners are investing in the long-term lifespan and aesthetic of their roof, addressing problems at the core rather than simply covering them up.

Cost: Short-Term Savings vs. Long-Term Investment

One of the main reasons homeowners might consider a roof sealing solution or roofing membrane is the lower upfront cost. Sealing is cheaper in the short term, making it an attractive option.

While the initial expense of sealing may be lower, there might be a need for repeated applications and the potential of frequent repairs can quickly add up over time. Additionally, if sealing fails to address underlying structural issues, the homeowner may be faced with more costly repairs in the future.

Re-roofing though, with a higher upfront investment, can be seen as a cost-effective solution in the long-term. With a longer lifespan and fewer maintenance requirements, a re-roofed home can save homeowners from the need for frequent repairs and reapplications. A new roof is also a good consideration when thinking about the resale value of your home, with a new roof being much more appealing to buyers than a roof that has simply been sealed over.

Aesthetic Limitations: Fresh Look vs. Quick Fix

Another factor to consider when choosing between sealing and re-roofing is the aesthetic impact of your choice. Roof sealing solutions and roofing membranes can temporarily improve the appearance of a roof, but they are limited in what they can offer in terms of style and customisation.

For homeowners interested in updating the style, colour, or overall aesthetic of their roof, re-roofing offers far more flexibility. With a wide variety of profiles and colours available, re-roofing offers homeowners the opportunity to completely transform the look and feel of their home. This is particularly important for those looking to increase curb appeal or add value to their property.

Re-roofing, the Smarter Long-Term Choice

While roof sealing solutions may seem appealing due to their potential lower upfront cost and ability to provide a quick fix, they may come with limitations in terms of longevity, limited aesthetics and cost effectiveness in the long term. For homeowners looking for a comprehensive, long-term solution, re-roofing with COLORSTEEL® is a smart choice. With its extended corrosion to perforation warranties, opportunity to address underlying issues, long-term cost savings, and aesthetic advantages, re-roofing provides a more permanent and reliable solution for maintaining and enhancing the value of your home.

In the end, while sealing may be a good option for those seeking a temporary fix, homeowners should consider the bigger and longer-term picture. By investing in re-roofing, you are not only protecting your home for decades to come but also enhancing its overall appearance and value. When it comes to your roof, a long-term solution is almost always the better investment.

Re-roofing vs Roof Sealing FAQs

Should I Re-Roof or use a Sealing Solution or Liquid Membrane?

What long term security do the two different options offer?

When it comes to longevity, what do I need to consider?

What costs are involved?

Are there any aesthetic limitations?

View your moodboard